Abstracts
of the April 2007 Issue
Considerations about enamel microabrasion after 18 years
Renato Herman Sundfeld,
dds, ms, phd,
Theodore P. Croll,
dds,
André Luiz Fraga Briso,
dds, ms, phd,Rodrigo
Sversut de Alexandre,
dds, ms, phd
&
Daniel Sundfeld
Neto,
dds
Abstract:
Purpose: To review of the current status of
enamel microabrasion method and its results 18 years after the
development and application of this method. Methods: A
technique performing enamel microabrasion with hydrochloric acid
mixed with pumice and other techniques employing a commercially
available compound of hydrochloric acid and fine-grit silicon
carbide particles in a water-soluble paste have been described.
Much has been learned about the application of this esthetic
technique, long-term treatment results and microscopic changes
to the enamel surface that has significant clinical
implications. The latest treatment protocol is presented and
photographic case histories document the treatment results.
Clinical observations made over 18 years are discussed.
Results: According to our findings, the dental enamel
microabrasion technique is a highly satisfactory, safe and
effective procedure. (Am J Dent 2007;20:67-72).
Clinical
significance: The enamel microabrasion technique was
developed as an method of eliminating enamel texture
irregularities and discoloration defects and improving the
appearance of teeth. It is a conservative procedure that has
proven to be safe and clinically effective.
:
Dr. Renato Herman Sundfeld, Department of Restorative Dentistry,
Araçatuba Dental School–UNESP, Rua José
Bonifácio 1193, São Paulo, CEP16015-050, Brazil. E-:
sundfeld@foa.unesp.br
Use of ultrasonography for the diagnosis
of temporomandibular joint disorders: A review
Marcello Melis,
dmd, rpharm,
Simona Secci,
md
&
Caroline Ceneviz,
dds, ms
Abstract:
Purpose: To evaluate the reliability of ultrasonography in
the diagnosis of temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorders.
Methods: A review of the literature was
performed, searching for all articles published between 1966 and
2006, and examining the ones which met the selection criteria.
Results: Ultrasonography sensitivity ranged from 13-100%
for the evaluation of disc displacement (DD), from 70.6-83.9%
for the evaluation of joint effusion (JE), and from 70-94% for
the evaluation of condylar erosion (CE). Specificity ranged from
62-100% for the evaluation of DD, from 73.7-100% for the
evaluation of JE, and from 20-100% for the evaluation of CE.
Accuracy ranged from 51.5-100% for the evaluation of DD, from
72.2-95% for the evaluation of JE, and from 67-94% for the
evaluation of CE. (Am J Dent 2007;20:73-78).
Clinical significance:
Ultrasonography is a noninvasive and inexpensive diagnostic
procedure that can be suggested for the evaluation of TMJ
disorders, with particular accuracy in the detection of disc
displacement and joint effusion. Limitations are especially
related to the scarce accessibility of the medial part of the
TMJ structures, and the need for trained and calibrated
operators.
:
Dr. Marcello Melis, Via Grosseto, 1, 09125 Cagliari, Italy. E-:
marcellomelis01@libero.it
Clinical effectiveness of a dentifrice
containing triclosan and a copolymer for controlling breath odor
Naresh C. Sharma,
dds,
H. Jack Galustians,
bs,
Jimmy Qaqish,
bs,
Anna Galustians,
bs,
Kedar Rustogi,
dds,
Margaret E. Petrone, jd, Patricia Chaknis,
bs,
Laura García,
bs,
Anthony R. Volpe,
dds, ms
& Howard M. Proskin,
phd
Abstract:
Purpose: To investigate in a double-blind
clinical study the effectiveness of a dentifrice containing
triclosan and a copolymer (Colgate Total Toothpaste) for
controlling breath odor 12 hours after brushing the teeth.
Methods: A panel of four expert judges using a nine-point
hedonic scale evaluated breath odor. Following a baseline
evaluation of breath odor, prospective study subjects who
presented breath odor scores above the threshold value for
unpleasant breath odor were stratified by score, and randomized
into two treatment groups. Subjects were provided with a
soft-bristled toothbrush, and brushed their teeth thoroughly in
their regular and customary manner with their assigned
dentifrice. Subjects refrained from dental hygiene, breath
mints, or mouthrinses for the next 12 hours, after which they
were once again evaluated for breath odor. 76 adult male and
female subjects from the Mississauga, Ontario, Canada area
participated in the study. Results: At 12 hours after
brushing their teeth, subjects in both dentifrice treatment
groups presented mean breath odor scores which were
statistically significantly lower than the mean scores observed
at baseline. However, the difference between the mean 12-hour
breath odor score for the Colgate Total group was 4.65, which is
within the range of values corresponding to pleasant breath
odor; whereas the mean 12-hour breath odor score for the placebo
group was 6.11, which is above the threshold value corresponding
to unpleasant breath odor. Thus, the results of this
double-blind study, conducted according to Guidelines by the
Council on Scientific Affairs of the American Dental
Association, support the conclusion that Colgate Total
dentifrice provides effective control of breath odor at 12 hours
after brushing the teeth. (Am J Dent 2007;20:79-82).
Clinical
significance: The results of this double-blind study support
the conclusion that Colgate Total dentifrice provides effective
control of breath odor at 12 hours after brushing the teeth.
:
Dr. Anthony R. Volpe, Colgate-Palmolive Technology Center, 909
River Road, Piscataway, NJ 08854, USA. E-:
tony_volpe@colpal.com
Degradation of thermo-mechanically
loaded adhesive Class V restorations after 18 months of water
storage
Tissiana Bortolotto,
dr
med dent,
Marco Ferrari,
md, dds, phd,
Franklin Tay,
bdsc
(hons), phd
& Ivo Krejci,
prof
dr med dent
Abstract:
Purpose: To assess in vitro the hydrolytic stability
of adhesive systems in Class V composite restorations bonded to
enamel and dentin. Methods: 16 groups of Class V cavities
restored with different adhesive systems and challenged with
thermal and mechanical loading under the simulation of dentin
fluid were evaluated after an 18-month period of water storage
at 37°C. The marginal adaptation of these restorations was
quantified by evaluation of gold-coated epoxy replicas with
scanning electron microscopy at x200 magnification. Results:
The percentages of “continuous margin” after 18 months of water
storage with respect to the total marginal length ranged from
62.9 (5.4)% to 18.5 (3.2)% with significant differences observed
among the groups (Bonferroni test P< 0.05). The range in enamel
was from 71.8 (14.2)% to 8.9 (6.4)% and in dentin from 94.3
(5.1)% to 0.0 (0.0)%. Marginal adaptation of all the materials
tested was affected by water storage, either in enamel, in
dentin, or both. None of the restorative systems tested
exhibited hydrolytically stable marginal adaptation. (Am J
Dent 2007;20:83-89).
Clinical
significance: Both enamel and dentin margins of adhesive
restorations showed hydrolytic degradation. This may compromise
the clinical performance of the restorations.
:
Prof. Dr. Ivo Krejci, Division of Cariology and
Endodontology, School of Dentistry, University of Geneva, 19,
Rue Barthélemy-Menn, CH-1205 Geneva, Switzerland. E-:
Ivo.Krejci@medecine.unige.ch
Effect of manual and powered
toothbrushes on orthodontic bracket bond strength
Franklin
García-Godoy,
dds, ms
&
Marko de Jager,
phd,
ms
Abstract:
Purpose: To assess in vitro the effect of manual and
powered toothbrushes on the bond strength of orthodontic
brackets. Methods: Specimens of orthodontic brackets
bonded to the surfaces of extracted teeth were exposed to one of
two powered toothbrushes (Sonicare Elite, Braun Oral-B 3D Excel)
or a manual toothbrush (Oral-B 35) for the equivalent of a
2-year exposure to brushing in the presence of toothpaste
slurry. Control specimens underwent no brushing. For each
treatment, 10 specimens were tested and evaluated. Shear bond
strength of the orthodontic bracket to the tooth surface was
assessed after exposure to simulated brushing. ANOVA was used to
analyze the data. Results: No differences in orthodontic
bracket bond strength were observed between any of the three
treatments and the control. The evaluated toothbrushes did not
adversely affect the in vitro bonding strength of
orthodontic brackets, suggesting they are safe to use in
orthodontic patients. (Am J Dent 2007:90-92).
Clinical significance:
The
evaluated toothbrushes did not adversely affect the
in
vitro
bonding strength of orthodontic brackets, suggesting they are
safe to use in orthodontic patients.
:Dr.
Franklin García-Godoy, College of Dental Medicine, Nova
Southeastern University, 3200 South University Drive, Fort
Lauderdale, FL 33328, USA. E-:
fgarciagodoy@gmail.com
Remineralization of primary root
caries lesions using an amine fluoride rinse and dentifrice
twice a day
Lars G. Petersson,
dds, odont
dr,
Ulf Hakestam,
dds, odont
dr,
Amir Baigi,
phd
& Edward Lynch,
bsentsc,
fds, ma, phd
Abstract: Purpose: To assess the clinical effect of daily
use of a toothpaste and mouthrinse, both containing amine
fluoride, on primary root caries lesions (PRCL) in an adult
caries risk population. Methods: A clinical trial based
on male and female subjects, 55-81 years of age, randomly
assigned into two equal groups (Groups A and B). Fifty subjects
allocated to Group A used a fluoride toothpaste twice a day, (Elmex
sensitive toothpaste, 1400 ppm F) plus a mouthrinse twice a day
with 10 ml of a fluoride solution (Elmex sensitive rinse
containing 250 ppm F). The fluoride used was amine fluoride and
potassium fluoride (AmF/KF, 1:1). Subjects in Group B used the
same fluoride toothpaste plus a placebo mouth rinse solution
without fluoride. At baseline, a total of 420 PRCL were
clinically recorded as either soft (score 3) or leathery (score
2). Parallel and blind recordings measuring electric resistance
of the selected PRCL were performed at baseline and after 3, 6,
9 and 12 months using an electrical caries monitor (ECM).
Prevalence of tooth sensitivity and subject’s satisfaction was
also measured in the two groups. Results: The clinical
results showed statistically significant higher numbers of
reversals of soft (score 3) and leathery (score 2) PRCL in Group
A compared to Group B. After 12 months, the number of soft PRCL
(score 3) decreased in Group A from 74% at baseline to 11%
compared with 73% to 46% in Group B. After 12 months, 67% of the
PRCL became hard (score 1) in Group A compared to only 7% in
Group B (P< 0.001). Statistically significant higher (P< 0.001)
ECM mean (sd) log10
resistance values were recorded for the subjects in Group A,
2.67 (2.56) kOhm compared to 2.12 (1.88) kOhm in Group B. Tooth
sensitivity was substantially reduced after 12 months, by 56% in
Group A compared to 20% in Group B. (Am J Dent
2007;20:93-96).
Clinical
significance: The results of this paper show that rinsing
and toothbrushing with amine fluoride dentifrice twice a day
significantly remineralizes active soft and leathery primary
root caries lesions with a substantial reduction of tooth
sensitivity. The ECM is a useful and supplementary tool for
objectively measuring remineralization of primary root caries
lesions.
:
Dr. Lars G. Petersson, Dental and Maxillofacial Unit,
Central Hospital, Halmstad, S-301 85, Sweden. E-:
lars.g.petersson@thalland.se
Micromorphology and surface roughness
of sound and demineralized enamel and dentin bleached with a 10%
carbamide peroxide bleaching agent
Roberta Tarkany Basting,
dds, ms, scd,
phd
Antonio Luiz Rodrigues Jr.,
dds, ms, scd
&
Mônica Campos Serra,
dds, ms, scd
Abstract:
Purpose: To evaluate the micromorphology and surface
roughness of sound and demineralized enamel and dentin treated
with a 10% carbamide peroxide bleaching agent in situ for
3 weeks. Methods: A 10% carbamide peroxide bleaching
agent, Opalescence (OPA) was evaluated and a placebo agent (PLA)
not containing carbamide peroxide, was used as a control group.
Forty dental slabs [10 sound enamel slabs (SE), 10 demineralized
enamel slabs (DE), 10 sound dentin slabs (SD) and 10
demineralized dentin slabs (DD)] were randomly fixed on the
facial surface of the first maxillary molars and second
maxillary premolars of 10 volunteers. Demineralized enamel and
dentin fragments were obtained by a dynamic model using
demineralizing and remineralizing solutions. The volunteers were
divided into two groups that received the bleaching or the
placebo agent in different sequences and periods in a double
blind 2 x 2 cross-over study with a wash-out period of 2 weeks.
Roughness was performed on the slab surfaces followed by
scanning electron microscope (SEM) evaluations. The images were
evaluated by three calibrated examiners in duplicate in two
different periods at x1500 (SE and DE) and x2000 original
magnification (SD and DD). Results: The Wilcoxon test
showed significant differences in roughness for SE and DE
treated with OPA or PLA, with rougher surfaces treated with OPA.
No differences in roughness were observed for SD or DD treated
with OPA or PLA. As the Kappa value for the inter-examiner
agreement of SEM evaluations showed “moderate” reproducibility
(0.41< k< 0.60) in Period 1 and “substantial” (0.61< k< 0.8) in
Period 2, the latter was considered for the statistical
analysis. The McNemar test showed no significant differences
between SE, DE, SD or DD treated with OPA or PLA. (Am J Dent
2007;20:97-102).
Clinical
significance: In a roughness evaluation, enamel surfaces
seemed to be more affected by bleaching agents than dentin.
However, these changes were not reflected as micromorphology
alterations.
:
Prof. Dr. Roberta Tarkany Basting, Faculdade de
Odontologia e Centro de Pesquisas Odontológicas São Leopoldo
Mandic, Departamento de Odontologia Restauradora – Dentística,
Rua José Rocha Junqueira, 13, Swift, Campinas, SP, CEP:
13045-755 Brazil. E-:
rbasting@yahoo.com
Influence of ceramic pre-treatments on
tensile bond strength and mode of failure of resin bonded to
ceramics
Noéli Boscato,
dds, msc,
Álvaro Della Bona,
dds, mmedsci,
phd
& Altair Antoninha Del Bel Cury,
dds, phd
Abstract:
Purpose: To evaluate the effect of ceramic surface
treatments on tensile bond strength (σ) and the mode of failure
of a resin bonded to a feldspathic glass and a low-crystalline
ceramic, testing the hypothesis that a silica coating treatment
is unnecessary for both the glass and the low-crystalline
ceramic. Methods: 10 blocks of each the feldspathic glass
(V7-VITAVM7) and the leucite-based ceramic (E1-IPS Empress) were
fabricated and polished. Five blocks of each ceramic were
treated as follows: 9.5% hydrofluoric acid for 60 seconds; and
silica coating using Cojet System for 15 seconds. After silane
coating, an adhesive resin and a composite were applied and
polymerized. The composite-ceramic blocks were cut to produce
bar-shaped specimens (n=30) that were stored in distilled water
at 37°C for 7 days before tensile loading to failure in a
universal testing machine. Data were statistically analyzed
using analysis of variance, Tukey’s test (α = .01) and Weibull
analysis. Fracture surfaces were examined to determine the mode
of failure. Results: The Weibull modulus (m) and mean σ
value (MPa) of Group E1HF (29.8±4.5) were significantly higher
than other Groups (P=.0001). There was no statistical difference
between Groups E1CS (24.6±5.6) and V7HF (22.3±4.0). Group V7CS
showed the lowest m and mean σ values (15.7±6.9) (P=.0001). All
fractures occurred within the adhesion zone. (Am J Dent
2007;20:103-108).
Clinical
significance: Silica coating is not the pre-treatment of
choice for bonding the glass and the low-crystalline ceramic to
resin. Hydrofluoric acid etching produced the highest m and σ
values of resin to both ceramics (V7 and E1) tested.
:
Dr. Alvaro Della Bona, University of Passo Fundo, School
of Dentistry, Campus I, Highway BR285, PO Box 611, Passo Fundo,
RS, 99001-970, Brazil. E-:
dbona@upf.br
Degradation of resin-bonded
human dentin after 3 years of storage
Franklin García-Godoy,
dds, ms,
Franklin R. Tay,
BDSc (Hons), FADM, PhD,
David H. Pashley,
DMD, FADM,
PhD,
Albert Feilzer,
DDS, PHD,
L. Tjäderhane,
DDS, PhD
& Edna L. Pashley,
DMD, MEd
Abstract:
Purpose: To test, in vitro, the null hypothesis that
there was no difference in the ultrastructure of
adhesive-bonded, acid-etched dentin aged under accelerated
conditions in mineral oil or artificial saliva. Methods:
Beams of human dentin bonded with three total-etch adhesives
were retrieved from the two storage media after 3 years and
prepared for transmission electron microscopy. Results:
Hybrid layers from specimens aged in mineral oil exhibited
structural integrity of the collagen network. Conversely,
abnormal hybrid layers were seen in specimens aged in artificial
saliva, with progressive disintegration of the fibrillar network
to the extent that it was beyond detection by collagen staining.
Self-destruction of collagen matrices can occur in
resin-infiltrated dentin, and to a lesser degree, in mineralized
dentin in the absence of bacterial or salivary enzymes. (Am J
Dent 2006;19:109-113).
Clinical
significance: Self-destruction of collagen matrices can
occur in resin-infiltrated dentin, and to a lesser degree, in
mineralized dentin in the absence of bacterial or salivary
enzymes.
:
Dr. Franklin García-Godoy, College of Dental Medicine, Nova
Southeastern University, 3200 South University Drive, Fort
Lauderdale, Florida 33328, USA. E-:
fgarciagodoy@gmail.com
Microtensile bond strength of
sealant and adhesive systems applied to occlusal primary enamel
Ana Cláudia D. Ramires-Romito,
dds, ms,
Alessandra Reis, dds,
phd,
Alessandro Dourado Loguercio,
dds, ms, phd,
Vinícius D. Hipólito,
dds, ms, Mário
Fernando de Goes,
dds, ms, phd,
Julio da Motta Singer,
phd
& Rosa Helena Miranda Grande,
dds, ms, phd
Abstract: Purpose: To compare the microtensile bond
strength (µTBS) of a self-etch adhesive system (OptiBond Solo
Self-Etch Adhesive System), two total etch adhesive system (OptiBond
FL; OptiBond Solo), and a conventional sealant (Clinpro) applied
to the occlusal surface of primary molars under saliva
contamination. Methods: Sealant and adhesive systems were
applied under manufacturers’ specifications with or without
previous saliva contamination. After storage in distilled water
at 37ºC for 24 hours, the specimens were longitudinally
sectioned perpendicularly to the adhesive interface to obtain
sticks (0.6 mm2)
which were tested under a tensile load of 0.5 mm/minute. The
bond failure modes were evaluated via scanning electron
microscope. Repeated measures ANOVA followed by multiple
comparisons using Bonferroni’s technique was used to evaluate
the effects of adhesive system and saliva contamination. The
pre-test debonded specimens were included in the computation of
the µTBS of each tooth. Results: No
association between failure mode and the values of µTBS was
observed (P= 0.3605). The majority of fractures were of mixed
type; no cohesive failure of enamel or composite resin was
observed. No significant effect of saliva contamination was
detected (P= 0.2044). OptiBond FL and Clinpro had equivalent
average µTBS (34.5 ± 2.2 MPa and 45.1 ± 3.2 MPa, respectively)
which are significantly higher than the corresponding average
µTBS for OptiBond Solo Plus and OptiBond Solo SE which may also
be considered equivalent (19.1 ± 2.3 MPa and 9.8 ± 2.3 MPa,
respectively). (Am J Dent 2007;20:114-120).
Clinical
significance: Except for the conventional sealant, all
adhesive systems showed similar performance on dry and
contaminated primary enamel surface. However, the total etch
two-step adhesive system provided the highest resin-enamel bond
strength values on the occlusal surface of primary molars and
seemed to be the best option for fissure sealing.
:
Prof. Dr. Rosa Helena Miranda Grande, Department of Dental
Materials, Faculty of Dentistry, University of São Paulo,
Avenida Lineu Prestes, 2227 – Cidade Universitária, 05508-000
São Paulo, SP, Brazil. E-:
grande@usp.br
Fracture strength of restored premolars
Guilherme Brião Camacho,
ms, dds, phd,
Mariane Gonçalves,
ms, dds, phd,
Tomio Nonaka, ms,
dds, phd
&
Angela Brys Osório,
ms
Abstract:
Purpose: To evaluate the fracture resistance (axial
compressive strength) of premolars restored with different
dental materials under two axial loads. Methods: Fracture
strength was performed using two metal spheres with 3 mm and 9
mm diameter. Five restorative techniques were chosen for MOD
cavity preparations (n=10): (1) direct resin composite
restorations (Z-250); (2) indirect resin composite restorations
(Z-250 and RelyX); (3) ceramic inlays (Vitadur Alpha); (4)
conventional amalgam restorations (GS-80); (5) bonded amalgam
restorations. The restored teeth were compared to human
caries-free premolars (Group 6/control). Enforce resin cement
was used for ceramic and amalgam adhesive restorative
techniques, according to the manufacturers’ instructions.
Whenever required, the teeth were conditioned by the total etch
technique. Results: The ANOVA analysis pointed out a
significant difference among the groups (P< 0.01) and the “site”
factor (P< 0.1). The ceramic restorations presented the highest
values for fracture strength and were similar to the control
group. The statistical results of direct and indirect resin
composite restorations were similar but inferior to the control
group. The amalgam restorations (conventional and bonded)
presented the lowest values, with no difference between them.
All amalgam groups displayed lower strengths when the load was
applied on the central fossa (3 mm Ø sphere) compared to load
applied on cusps (9 mm Ø sphere). (Am J Dent
2007;20:121-124).
Clinical
significance: The loads similar to chewing of solid food is
relevant to fracture strength, which occurs at the central fossa
where the risk of fracture is higher. The fracture strength of
the different restorative techniques was product-related.
:
Prof. Dr. Mariane Gonçalves, Faculty of Dentistry, Department of
Dental Materials and Prosthesis, University of Ribeirão Preto,
Avenida do Café, s/n, Ribeirão Preto – SP, CEP 14040-904,
Brazil. E-:
ane.gon@netsite.com.br
One-year clinical performance of
self-etch adhesives in posterior restorations
Jorge Perdigão,
dmd, ms, phd,
Maristela Dutra-Corrêa,
dds, ms,
Natália Castilhos,
dds,
André R.P. Carmo,
dds,
ms, phd,
Camillo Anauate-Netto,
dds,
ms, phd,
Hiram J.D. Cordeiro,
dds,
ms, phd,
Ricardo Amore,
dds,
ms, phd
& Hugo R. Lewgoy,
dds,
ms, phd
Abstract: Purpose: To evaluate the 1-year clinical
performance of three self-etching adhesives (Adper Prompt L-Pop,
Clearfil S3
Bond, iBond) in posterior composite restorations using one
etch&rinse adhesive (One-Step Plus) as control. Methods:
Upon approval by the Institutional Review Board, 121
restorations were inserted in 38 subjects. The adhesives were
applied as per manufacturers’ instructions. Preparations were
restored with a nanofilled resin composite (Filtek Supreme) and
evaluated at baseline, 6 months, and 1 year. Statistical
analyses included the Chi-square distribution with the McNemar
non-parametric test (P< 0.05). Results: At 1 year, 111
restorations in 35 subjects were evaluated using the USPHS
modified criteria. No significant changes were observed for the
etch&rinse adhesive One-Step Plus. At 1 year the number of Alfa
ratings decreased significantly for Clearfil S3
Bond and for iBond in the categories color match, marginal
staining, and marginal adaptation. For Adper Prompt L-Pop,
marginal adaptation at 1 year was significantly worse than at
baseline. Postoperative sensitivity to air improved
significantly for Adper Prompt L-Pop, Clearfil S3
Bond, and iBond. When the evaluation criteria were paired at 1
year, iBond resulted in a significantly lower number of Alfa
ratings than any of the other adhesives for color match,
marginal staining, and marginal adaptation. One-Step Plus
resulted in a greater number of Alfa ratings for marginal
adaptation than either Adper Prompt L-Pop or Clearfil S3
Bond. Marginal adaptation was significantly better for Clearfil
S3 Bond
than for Adper Prompt L-Pop. The post-operative sensitivity
measured at 1 year for Adper Prompt L-Pop was statistically
better than that for One-Step Plus. (Am J Dent
2007:20:125-133).
Clinical
significance: Etch&rinse adhesives are still the benchmark
for clinical performance in posterior restorations. Some
self-etch adhesives may not perform at an acceptable level.
:
Dr. Jorge Perdigão, Division of Operative Dentistry, Department
of Restorative Sciences, University of Minnesota, 8-450 Moos
Tower, 515 SE Delaware St., Minneapolis, MN 55455, USA. E-:
perdi001@umn.edu
Inhibition of enamel demineralization
by a bioerodible fluoridated resin
Jeffrey Miles
Mazzawi,
dmd,
Timothy Henson, dmd
& Kevin J. Donly,
dds, ms
Abstract: Purpose: To investigate the efficacy of a
bioerodible fluoridated resin on inhibition of enamel
demineralization. Methods: Eighteen extracted permanent
molars were sectioned mesiodistally to obtain 36 caries-free
enamel surfaces. Each sample was prepared by painting an
acid-protective varnish, excluding a 2 x 8 mm window on either
the buccal or lingual surface. The windows of exposed enamel
were randomly divided into three separate groups (n= 12). Group
1 received an application of a 5% (by weight) sodium fluoride
varnish. Group 2 had an experimental 5% sodium fluoride
bioerodible resin applied to the window. Group 3 was left
untreated and acted as a control. The samples were then exposed
to an artificial caries challenge for 17 days, until a visible
white spot lesion had been created on the control group. The
samples were brushed for 1 minute daily. Following the acid
challenge, the teeth were sectioned longitudinally to obtain 100
µm sections. Sections were then photographed under polarized
light. Quantitatively the areas of the lesions were measured by
utilizing a computerized imaging system. Finally, a comparison
was made between mean lesion sizes of the sample groups in order
to determine their respective efficacy of enamel
demineralization inhibition. Results: The mean areas (µm)2
of the artificial lesions (± SD) were: bioerodible fluoridated
resin 3,785 ± 1,794; fluoride varnish 7,362 ± 2,853, and control
11,398 ± 4,238. ANOVA was performed and identified a significant
variance (P< 0.001). Tukey's multiple comparison test
demonstrated that bioerodible fluoridated resin had
significantly less enamel demineralization than the fluoride
varnish and control groups (P< 0.05). The fluoride varnish group
demonstrated significantly less enamel demineralization than the
control group (P< 0.05). (Am J Dent 2007;20:134-136).
Clinical
significance: A bioerodible fluoridated resin could offer an
enhanced demineralization inhibition effect compared to
currently available products.
:
Dr. Kevin J. Donly, Department of Pediatric Dentistry, Dental
School, University of Texas Health Science Center at San
Antonio, 7703 Floyd Curl Drive, San Antonio, TX 78229-3900, USA.
E-:
donly@uthscsa.edu |